Britse uitspraak: beroep op Chavez en artikel 8 EVRM in zaak met dementerende ouder die bij Britse zoon wil blijven
UPPER TRIBUNAL JUDGE O'CALLAGHAN
Between
Mr. IQBAL [K]
Mrs BALQEES [A]
(ANONYMITY DIRECTION NOT MADE)
Appellants
and
THE SECRETARY OF STATE FOR THE HOME DEPARTMEN
The
appellants were first issued with multi-visit visas in 2010 and 2004
respectively. Until their latest visit they acted in compliance with the
requirements of their visas. On 10 November 2015 they were issued with
6-month family visit visas and subsequently entered this country on 27
December 2015. On 13 April 2016 they applied for derivative residence
cards, relying upon the Court of Justice judgment in
Case-34/09 Ruiz 
Zambrano v Office National de l'Emploi (ONEm) EU:C:2011:124, [2012] QB 265.
The respondent refused the applications by a decision dated 29 October
2016, from which the appellants enjoyed no right of appeal.
6. On 4 May 2017 the respondent issued the appellants with notices of liability to removal. The appellants subsequently applied for leave to remain on human rights (articles 3 and 8) grounds. The respondent refused their application by a decision dated 2 August 2017. Four further representations were served and rejected. A fifth application for leave to remain on human rights (article 8) grounds was submitted on 19 October 2018 and accepted by the respondent as satisfying the fresh claim requirements of paragraph 353 of the Immigration Rules ('the Rules'). The respondent refused to grant the appellants leave to remain in this country by a decision dated 2 July 2019. The appellants proceeded to exercise their right of appeal to the First-tier Tribunal.
7. The appellants live in Bedfordshire with their son, Mubbeen, their daughter-in-law and their two grandchildren, who are presently aged 8 and 5. A second son, Sohail, resides with his family in London.
8. Prior to their arrival in this country in December 2015, the appellants resided in Pakistan with their son, Faisal. He subsequently relocated to the USA with his family in 2019. Another son, Javed, continues to reside in Pakistan with his wife and three children, one of whom is aged 18 and has autism. His condition is such that Javed is required to work at home to provide care because his wife is unable to physically cope with the strength of their son when he becomes angry. The appellants have two daughters, Sayeda and Asma, who are married and reside with their families in Pakistan.
(...)
De zaak wordt verloren omdat de vreemdelingen geen bewijs leveren over opvang in Pakistan en het echtpaar samen is en voor elkaar kan zorgen.
"As to Mr. [K], I observe that there is no cure for dementia. Available
medication seeks to temporarily reduce symptoms, but over time there
will be deterioration. Consequently, I observe that there may come a
time when the illness reaches such a point, when coupled with Mrs. [A]'s
own health concerns, that removal may be a disproportionate
interference with protected article 8 rights. However, this requires an
evidential assessment, and a decision-maker would require appropriate
medical diagnosis and up-to-date prognosis, which is presently missing
in this matter. Such time has therefore not presently been reached."
Lees hier verder: https://www.bailii.org/cgi-bin/format.cgi?doc=/uk/cases/UKAITUR/2020/HU118572019.html&query=(Zambrano)
Interessant artikel? Deel het eens met uw netwerk en help mee met het verspreiden van de bekendheid van dit blog. Er staan wellicht nog meer artikelen op dit weblog die u zullen boeien. Kijk gerust eens rond. Zelf graag wat willen plaatsen? Mail dan webmaster@vreemdelingenrecht.com In verband met geldwolven die denken geld te kunnen claimen op krantenartikelen die op een blog als deze worden geplaatst maar na meestal een dag voor de krantenlezers aan leeswaardigheid hebben ingeboet terwijl wij vreemdelingenrecht specialisten ze soms wel nog jaren gebruiken om er een kopie van te maken voor een zaak ga ik over tot het plaatsen van alleen het eerste stukje. Ja ik weet het: de kans dat u doorklikt is geringer dan wanneer het hele artikel hier staat en een kopie van het orgineel maken handig kan zijn voor uw zaak. Wilt u zelf wat overnemen van dit weblog. Dat mag. Zet er alleen even een link bij naar het desbetreffende artikel zodat mensen niet alleen dat wat u knipt en plakt kunnen lezen maar dat ook kunnen doen in de context.
Subscribe to Vreemdelingenrecht.com blog by Email
Kijk ook eens op dit reisblog: https://www.europevisitandvisa.com/
Kijk ook eens op dit boekenblog bijvoorbeeld voor:
The invasion of the last free kingdom of Sri Lanka - And the love of a girl for an elephant - Review of "The Elephant Keeper's daughter"
http://www.dutchysbookreviewsandfreebooks.com/2021/02/the-invasion-of-last-free-kingdom-of.html
Reacties